The risks that killed MF Global PDF Print E-mail
Wednesday, 01 February 2012 18:26
A Congressional subcommittee will examine the risks that led to MF Global's downfall in a hearing on Thursday.

Former MF Global CEO Jon Corzine appears on Capitol Hill in December.

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- It's been three months since MF Global became the eighth-largest bankruptcy in U.S. history. Did anyone see this coming?

Well, a few people had some idea, and a congressional subcommittee will hear from them on Capitol Hill Thursday.

One former MF Global executive who is slated to testify clashed with ex-CEO Jon Corzine over the risks the firm was taking on before being ousted from his position.

Michael Roseman, MF Global's former chief risk officer, warned early of the dangers in the firm's massive bets on troubled European debt. He was replaced early last year by Michael Stockman, who is also scheduled to appear.

"I discussed my concerns about the positions and the risk scenarios with Mr. Corzine and others," Roseman said in testimony submitted ahead of the hearing. "However, the risk scenarios I presented were challenged as being implausible."

MF Global (MFGLQ) filed for bankruptcy on Halloween following a frantic week in which executives including Corzine, the former CEO and an ex-governor and senator from New Jersey, attempted to offload assets and sell the business.

The firm had come under intense pressure in the previous days after its $6.3 billion investment in European debt came to public notice. Trading partners called for increased margin payments and clients took their business elsewhere, leaving the firm scrambling for cash to meet its obligations.

Corzine has acknowledged pushing MF Global's aggressive European bet strategy after arriving at the firm in 2010, anxious to take it to the ranks of Wall Street's elite.

The investments themselves didn't actually lose money, as Corzine noted in Congressional testimony in December. None of the bonds MF Global held came from countries that have defaulted and all were set to mature before 2013. But Europe's precarious finances and the massive leverage MF Global took on spooked investors and ultimately helped doom the firm.

While an examination of MF Global's risk management may be the main focus of Thursday's hearing, for the firm's former customers, the big question is what happened to their money.

Customer funds at futures brokers like MF Global are supposed to be protected even in the event of a bankruptcy. In MF Global's case, however, staffers were unable to account for roughly $1.2 billion in customer money that is now suspected to have been unlawfully appropriated for the firm's own purposes.

Ratings agencies under fire: Others set to be scrutinized Thursday are rating agencies Moody's and Standard & Poor's, which waited until just days before MF Global's bankruptcy to flag its European exposure even though the firm had disclosed it back in May.

By the time the rating agencies acted, the bets were already sparking concern among MF Global's trading partners. Then the downgrades sharply acclerated the firm's downward spiral.

"[T]he abruptness of the downgrades and the suddenness of MF Global's collapse raise questions about why the credit rating agencies did not consider MF Global's exposure to European sovereign debt until late October," the House committee said in a memo last week.

Moody's and S&P did not respond to requests for comment.

Also appearing Thursday is James Gellert, head of the smaller ratings agency Rapid Ratings International, which maintained a grim outlook on MF Global long before its larger counterparts did. Gellert noted in prepared testimony that MF Global's business model had been deteriorating for several years prior to its failure, and that the new risks in the European strategy only made its situation more precarious.

"Had MF Global offered a lower risk foundation, MF Global might have been able to withstand the failure of the new business strategy," Gellert said. "As it was, Mr. Corzine inherited an unhealthy company and made it worse by some high-stakes gambles." To top of page

First Published: February 1, 2012: 6:24 PM ET

 

Stocks to Watch

Prev Next

Get tougher on international trading - r…

Get tougher on international trading - regulator

CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler said the JP Morgan Chase losses highlight the need for tough international rules on financial trades.WASHINGTON (CNNMoney) -- A top regulator said on...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:1 Finance News

Read more

Stocks rebound on Europe hopes

Stocks rebound on Europe hopes

Click on chart to track stocksNEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. stocks bounced back Monday, after closing one of the worst weeks of the year, on renewed optimism...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:2 Finance News

Read more

Stocks get an early blue-chip boost

Stocks get an early blue-chip boost

U.S. stocks edged higher at the start of trading Monday on optimism over Europe.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. stocks edged higher Monday, after closing out one of...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:2 Finance News

Read more

Facebook stock falls below IPO price

Facebook stock falls below IPO price

Click chart for more on Facebook's stockNEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Facebook's stock slid below its offering price in premarket trading Monday, following a lackluster day of trading...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:2 Finance News

Read more

Fiscal cliff: Market sting may come soon…

Fiscal cliff: Market sting may come sooner

The sky over the Capitol may be clear. But the same can't be said about how Congress will handle the fiscal cliff.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- As...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:3 Finance News

Read more

How Iran could double its oil output

How Iran could double its oil output

Many analysts think Iran could double its oil output to nearly 7 million barrels per day. The catch is lifting sanctions.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- As Iran continues...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:3 Finance News

Read more

What's next for Greece

What's next for Greece

It's becoming increasingly likely Greece will be forced to drop the euro.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Efforts to keep Greece out of default and in the eurozone grow...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 21 May 2012 Hits:3 Finance News

Read more

JPMorgan Chase loss only going to get wo…

JPMorgan Chase loss only going to get worse

An overall drop in the market is exacerbating JPMorgan's losses tied to its bets on corporate bonds.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- One thing seems clear about JPMorgan...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 20 May 2012 Hits:5 Finance News

Read more

Nasdaq 'embarrassed' by Facebook glitche…

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- The chief executive of Nasdaq OMX said he was "embarrassed" after technical glitches caused Facebook's widely-anticipated IPO to be delayed Friday, according to several news reports.Issues...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 20 May 2012 Hits:4 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Storm clouds still gathering ove…

Stocks: Storm clouds still gathering over Greece

The S&P 500 has tumbled more than 7% in May already, and is on track for its worst monthly performance since May 2010, the month when...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 20 May 2012 Hits:6 Finance News

Read more

Facebook trading sets record IPO volume

Facebook trading sets record IPO volume

Facebook CEO and founder Mark Zuckerberg rang the opening bell remotely, from company headquarters in California.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Facebook's stock market debut finally came and went...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:13 Finance News

Read more

Facebook: Many mutual funds already have…

Facebook: Many mutual funds already have a stake

Facebook may only be making its public debut Friday but nearly 70 mutual funds have already snapped up pre-IPO shares on private markets.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Whether...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:12 Finance News

Read more

Anti-social: Zynga tumbles after Faceboo…

Anti-social: Zynga tumbles after Facebook IPO

Click the chart to track shares of Zynga.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Social media stocks just aren't feeling the love, despite Facebook's highly-anticipated stock market debut. Shares of...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:12 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Global fear trumps Facebook debu…

Stocks: Global fear trumps Facebook debut

Click on chart to track marketsNEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. investors resumed focus on the global issues plaguing world markets Friday, following a brief euphoric pop from...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:10 Finance News

Read more

Enough on Facebook! Buy Google or Apple

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Facebook is finally trading. And even though the stock didn't explode out of the gate, the company is still worth more than $100 billion. It shouldn't...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:15 Finance News

Read more

Facebook: 70 mutual funds already have a…

Facebook: 70 mutual funds already have a stake

Facebook may only be making its public debut Friday but nearly 70 mutual funds have already snapped up pre-IPO shares on private markets.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Whether...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:11 Finance News

Read more

Facebook IPO trading opens at $42

Facebook IPO trading opens at $42

Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg rang the opening Nasdaq bell from Facebook's headquarters in California.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Facebook's stock market debut is finally here -- and investors...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:13 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Europe fears vs. Facebook antici…

Stocks: Europe fears vs. Facebook anticipation

Click on chart to track marketsNEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. investors continue to worry about Europe's sovereign debt issues, with stocks opening little changed ahead of Facebook's...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:14 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Europe fears vs. Facebook

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. investors continue to worry about Europe's sovereign debt issues, with stocks opening little changed ahead of Facebook's debut on the Nasdaq.The Dow Jones industrial average...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:14 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Europe fears vs. Facebook

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. investors continue to worry about Europe's sovereign debt issues, with stocks opening little changed ahead of Facebook's debut on the Nasdaq.The Dow Jones industrial average...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:0 Finance News

Read more

Pre-Marketing: HP cuts deep

Pre-Marketing: HP cuts deep

From Cookistry.com * Chainsaw Meg: HP to cut 25,000 jobs * Income inequality: The talk TED won't let you see * Roger Ehrenberg: Is Facebook the next Blackstone? * Economist: Time to prepare for Greece's departure *...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:14 Finance News

Read more

Europe fears pressure world markets

Europe fears pressure world markets

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- European markets were mixed Friday as investors remained anxious about Spanish and Greek banks, while Asian stocks sold off sharply amid worries of...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:13 Finance News

Read more

Stocks: Facebook IPO vs. Europe worries

Stocks: Facebook IPO vs. Europe worries

Click on graphic for more premarket dataNEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. stocks were poised for a mixed open Friday as investor excitement over the Facebook initial public...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 18 May 2012 Hits:16 Finance News

Read more

Why Facebook won't start trading at the …

Why Facebook won't start trading at the opening bell

Want to buy a share of Facebook? You'll have to wait an hour or so after the opening bell to do it.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- The most...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 17 May 2012 Hits:15 Finance News

Read more

Why Facebook won't start trading at the …

Why Facebook won't start trading at the opening bell

Want to buy a share of Facebook? You'll have to wait an hour or so after the opening bell to do it.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- The most...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 17 May 2012 Hits:0 Finance News

Read more

Moody's downgrades Spanish banks

Moody's downgrades Spanish banks

The rating agency also downgraded four Spanish regions, two of them to junk.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Rating agency Moody's downgraded 16 Spanish banks on Thursday, the latest...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 17 May 2012 Hits:13 Finance News

Read more

Moody's downgrades Spanish banks

Moody's downgrades Spanish banks

The rating agency also downgraded four Spanish regions, two of them to junk.NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Rating agency Moody's downgraded 16 Spanish banks on Thursday, the latest...

Administrator - avatar Administrator 17 May 2012 Hits:0 Finance News

Read more